I Will Feed Them with Justice: Reign of Christ Sunday,Year A

The Very Rev’d Peter Elliott, DD

We have Benito Mussolini to that for the inauguration of the Feast of Christ the King.  In 1925 Pope Pius IX, instituted this feast to remind Christians that their allegiance was to their spiritual ruler in heaven as opposed to earthly supremacy, which was claimed by Benito Mussolini.  Authoritarian leaders then and now seek to dominate their worlds with the force of personality.  Pope Pius IX made a counter cultural move by challenging earthly power plays by lifting up the story and presence of Jesus Christ.

Originally scheduled for the end of October as a prelude to the Feasts of All Saints and All Souls in 1969, Pope Paul VI changed the observance to the Sunday before Advent with a new title the Solemnity of Our Lord Jesus Christ, King of the Universe (Domini Nostri Iesu Christi universorum Regis).  Some Anglicans and others in mainline denominations found the language of “King” problematic on political and gender grounds, so adapted the name to the Reign of Christ.  The Revised Common Lectionary uses both Feast of Christ the King and the Reign of Christ.

In the three-year lectionary cycle, the gospels subvert the hierarchical notion of “King” by emphasizing the irony that it’s the Crucified One who is regarded as sovereign: in Luke’s Year C features an account of the crucifixion (Luke 23:33–43); in Year B, the lectionary chooses 4th gospel’s the account of Jesus appearance before Pilate (John 18:33–37). And in Matthew’s year A the gospel is neither to Jesus’ trial nor crucifixion but his last teaching before the Passion narrative (Matthew 25:31–46). 

While all three gospel choices subvert any claims of Christian imperialism—none do that as powerfully as Matthew’s parable (is it a parable?) of the honouring those who have been compassionate to the suffering.  It’s important to note that Matthew’s version of the last judgement includes absolutely nothing about what people believe, nor about what their brand or style of religion is.  Those who are the blessed are those who treat ‘the least of those’ as Christ himself.  It is the logical extension of Matthew’s Beatitudes.  

And curiously it not only has resonances in Hebrew Scriptures but also in Islamic literature in Sahih Muslim Hadith 2569, a piece of Islamic tradition classified as a Hadith Qudsi, Compared with the Matthew text, the surprise is increased infinitely as it is Allah who confronts the people: “O son of Adam, I asked you for food but you did not feed me”. He will say: “My Lord, how can I feed You when You are the Lord of the worlds?” Allah will say: “Did you not know that such-and-such servant of Mine asked you for food but you did not feed him, and had you fed him you would have found Me with him?” (1)

Seeing the divine in feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, welcoming the stranger, clothing the naked, caring for the sick, and visiting those in prison is the essence of the message.   When you add in Pope Francis’s clear connection of how the ecological crisis affects humans and other animals then the work of this Wild Lectionary commentary can begin.


Commentary

Sermon Ideas

The results of 2026 US midterm elections stunned and surprised the public and pundits alike.  Many progressive candidates were supported by the “Matthew 25 network” as many Democratic candidates often referred to themselves.  It is a shorthand way of talking about the importance of compassion in the development of public policy.  Similar to the social dynamics that led to the creation of the observance of the Reign of Christ 1925, evoking Matthew 25 is a powerful way to critique the politics of authoritarianism.  

The more closely we read the appointed section of Matthew 25 the more it reveals about the brilliance of the author of this gospel.  Is it a parable?  Or is it prophetic writing?  Or is it a prelude to the Passion?  

Notice immediately that it does not begin with Matthew’s familiar phrase, “The kingdom of heaven is like...”  Rather it begins with a vision of the Son of Man (taking us to the Hebrew Scripture’s book of Daniel).  The Human One— a more inclusive way to express “Son of Man”—is imagined in a scene reminiscent of the book of Revelation. The Human One is surrounded by angels and seated on a throne.  All the nations are gathered there.  

And then in the text, the person of the Human One disappears or is transformed into a king.  The separation of sheep from goats begins those who have treated the least with compassion are invited into the kingdom, those who have not are accursed and sent into eternal punishment.

While it’s good news for those who were compassionate, it’s not so good for those who were not, and the king’s judgement is final and cruel.  

Two important points: 

  1.  This is a parody how kings--the authoritarian leaders-- deal with those who they perceive as their enemies.  Fascist leaders identify ones they blame for the problems of the time: immigrants, people of colour, sexual minorities.  This parable has those identified as ‘goats’ (scapegoats?): set apart as those who do not conform to whatever standards the ‘kings’ of the world have identified.  

  2. Note the placement of this passage within Matthew’s overall narrative.  The gospel appointed for the Reign of Christ comes immediately before Jesus tells his disciples, “You know that after two days the Passover is coming, and the Son of Man will be handed over to be crucified.” (Matthew 26:2) Here again is “The Son of Man who disappears into some kind of ‘king.’  

Can we see the gospel appointed for the Reign of Christ not so much as a parable, but as a prelude into the passion of Jesus. Everything Jesus identifies hungry and you gave me food... thirsty and you gave me something to drink...a stranger and you welcomed me... naked and you gave me clothing... sick and you took care of me... in prison and you visited me—all these things happen to Jesus in his passion story.  On the cross he said, “I am thirsty.”  At the cross, Peter said he did not know Jesus—making Jesus a stranger.  Jesus was stripped of his clothing, suffered physical pain, thrown into prison.  Jesus experienced everything that he identified with ‘the least of these.”   Jesus became the least of them.  But unlike the king at the end of Matthew 25, the Risen Christ returns with nothing but forgiving love.  Unlike the “judgy king” in the parable, the Risen King Jesus reigns in love.  This is our fairest Lord Jesus—ruler of all nature, the Godhead’s human one.   The reign of Christ over our lives and indeed over all the creation is one that is eternally renewing, eternally forgiving, eternally opening doors to new life—for the earth and all its creatures.

References/Endnotes

(1)  https://www.abuaminaelias.com/dailyhadithonline/2012/08/14/sadaqah-did-not-visit-me/

(2)  https://justiceunbound.org/ezekiel/

(3)  For extensive research on these themes see The Book of Ezekiel: A Help or a Hindrance for Environmental Ethics? by Michael A. Lyons in April 2021 in Horizons in Biblical Theology 

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350998558_The_Book_of_Ezekiel_A_Help_or_a_Hindrance_for_Environmental_Ethics

(4) See Ellen F. Davis’s Scripture, Culture, and Agriculture: An Agrarian Reading of the Bible.  Cambridge University Press, 2008

(5) Darr, Katheryn Pfisterer from "The Book of Ezekiel" in The New Interpreter's Bible (Volume 6, Abingdon Press)

(6) C. J. Dempsey, “Hope Amidst Crisis: A Prophetic Vision of Cosmic Redemption,” ‬‬ in‬ All Creation is Groaning: An Interdisciplinary Vision for Life in a Sacred Universe, ed. C. J. Dempsey and R. A. Butkus (Collegeville: The Liturgical Press, 2000),‬‬

(7) Richard Bauckham.   The Bible and Ecology: Rediscovering the Community of Creation.  Baylor University Press, 2010.

(8) Adapted freely from the commentary by Kristofer Phan Coffman found here https://www.workingpreacher.org/commentaries/revised-common-lectionary/christ-the-king/commentary-on-ephesians-115-23-15

(9)  https://dsc.duq.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1065&context=spiritan-horizons

Author Bio

Peter Elliott is a retired Anglican priest in private practice as a leadership coach and consultant.  He teaches at Vancouver School of Theology, and has written on arts and culture for the Anglican Journal.  Prior to his retirement he served as Dean of Christ Church Cathedral, Vancouver BC from 1994-2019.

Image Description

Images shows a herd of elk sillouhetted against an orange sunset. The elk are in a field, and one has an impressive set of horns.

Next
Next

Justice for Creation: Twenty Fifth Sunday After Pentecost Year A